Shao Ziqiang
Chief Physician
Department of Neurology, China-Japan Friendship Hospital
Health-Related Disorders
Insomnia: Prefer Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM). Insomnia is often a functional disorder, and TCM can provide effective treatment by differentiating patterns based on concepts like Qi, blood, Yin, and Yang. Western sedative and hypnotic drugs are prone to causing dependency and should only be used short-term.
Other Suboptimal Health Conditions: For symptoms such as general weakness, irritability, and poor appetite—conditions where Western medical tests show no abnormalities—TCM can offer effective holistic regulation.
Migraine: Prefer TCM. After confirming the diagnosis and ruling out organic issues, TCM regulation is advisable. Most migraines lack a clear organic cause and are functional disorders, for which Western medicine offers limited solutions.
Common Illnesses
Common Cold: Both TCM and Western medicine are applicable. Most colds are viral, though bacterial infections may coexist. TCM has advantages in antiviral treatment, while Western medicine offers more targeted antibacterial therapy.
For severe symptoms such as persistent high fever, cough, or headache, it is advisable to first undergo tests like a complete blood count or chest X-ray to clarify the cause and guide treatment.
Cervical Spondylosis: Prefer TCM. TCM massage and physical therapy are distinctive and effective, especially when combined with herbal medicine. However, it is crucial to seek treatment at a reputable TCM hospital, as improper massage techniques can be risky.
Lumbar Disc Herniation: Both TCM and Western medicine are suitable. TCM combined with physical therapy often yields good results, while Western medicine excels in surgical interventions.
Facial Paralysis Recovery: Prefer TCM. Western medicine has limited options for this condition, whereas acupuncture combined with physical therapy in TCM is reliable.
Nosebleeds: Both TCM and Western medicine are applicable. After ruling out organic causes (e.g., trauma, tumors, deformities, or blood disorders), TCM can be used for regulation.
Ophthalmic Diseases: Prefer Western medicine. Western medicine excels in diagnostics, surgical corrections, and ophthalmic formulations. TCM can provide auxiliary relief for symptoms like dryness, swelling, or pain.
Oral Diseases: Prefer Western medicine. Western dentistry offers advanced medical instruments and excels in surgical orthodontics and treatment. For non-organic issues like oral ulcers or gum swelling, TCM may be considered.
Indigestion: Prefer TCM. Holistic regulation of the spleen and stomach through TCM often yields more lasting results.
Constipation: Prefer TCM. Western laxatives are short-term solutions and should only be used as emergency measures. Overuse may lead to dependency.
Cardiovascular and Cerebrovascular Diseases (Hypertension, Heart Disease, Stroke, Cerebral Infarction): Prefer Western medicine. Western medicine has reliable evidence for controlling blood pressure and improving vascular obstruction.
TCM can help alleviate specific symptoms and be used as complementary therapy.
Skin Diseases
Acne: Combine TCM and Western medicine. Western medicine acts quickly to reduce inflammation and control oil but has significant side effects and is unsuitable for long-term use. TCM offers holistic, gentle, and lasting regulation.
Vitiligo: Both TCM and Western medicine have their merits. As a difficult-to-treat condition requiring long-term management, Western medicine focuses on topical treatments and laser therapy, while TCM emphasizes holistic regulation based on pattern differentiation.
Herpes Zoster: Both TCM and Western medicine are applicable. This viral infection has no specific antiviral treatment in Western medicine. Both approaches offer similar efficacy, with a focus on preventing complications and sequelae.
Athlete’s Foot: Both TCM and Western medicine are applicable. Topical treatments are generally effective, but Western antifungal drugs are more targeted. For stubborn cases, combining both approaches yields better results.
Idiopathic Hair Loss and Alopecia Areata: Prefer TCM. These conditions often lack clear causes and are challenging to treat with Western medicine. TCM approaches, focusing on Qi and blood deficiency, organ weakness, or damp-heat stasis, can be effective.
Eczema, Dermatitis, and Other Allergic Skin Conditions: Both TCM and Western medicine are applicable, depending on the diagnosis. For conditions with clear allergens (e.g., contact dermatitis or drug-induced dermatitis), Western medicine quickly controls symptoms and avoids triggers.
For complex, recurrent conditions like eczema or chronic urticaria, TCM can provide long-term regulation alongside Western treatment.
Gynecological Diseases
Infectious Diseases (e.g., Pelvic Inflammatory Disease, Vaginitis): Both TCM and Western medicine are applicable. Western medicine works faster for acute infections with identified pathogens, while TCM is more effective for chronic, recurrent inflammation.
Infertility: Identify the cause before choosing TCM or Western medicine. Western medicine is better for organic issues like fallopian tube blockage, while TCM excels in regulating functional disorders.
Primary Dysmenorrhea: Prefer TCM. Western medicine offers limited symptomatic relief, whereas TCM pattern differentiation provides more effective treatment.
Menstrual Disorders: Prefer TCM. Most are functional disorders, and TCM regulation is often more effective.
Menopausal Syndrome: Combine TCM and Western medicine. Western medicine may work faster for some, but TCM offers safer long-term regulation.
Pediatric Diseases
Both TCM and Western medicine have their strengths. Pediatric diseases often progress rapidly, so Western medicine is preferred for acute conditions to clarify the diagnosis and control symptoms promptly. For chronic conditions, TCM can be used during the recovery phase.
TCM massage is also effective for certain pediatric issues.
Major Illnesses (e.g., Tumors)
Prefer Western medicine. Early detection and treatment are critical. Western medicine excels in diagnostics, surgery, radiotherapy, and chemotherapy, especially in early-stage tumors. However, the side effects of surgery and drugs correlate with their efficacy (greater efficacy often means more side effects). Weigh the pros and cons under professional guidance.
TCM can help alleviate symptoms, reduce drug side effects, and improve quality of life. However, avoid blindly believing advertisements or unverified claims to prevent delaying treatment.
Although TCM and Western medicine can achieve similar results in treating diseases and aim to restore the body’s natural state of health, their approaches to pathology are fundamentally different.
When treating an illness, it is essential to first identify the cause and then determine the most suitable approach—TCM or Western medicine—based on the condition’s progression.